The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down two opinions today. One is an interlocutory appeal of an order denying a motion to transfer venue centered around an incorrect address listed with the Secretary of State and the other is an initial, arbitration-agreement skirmish in a lawsuit Mississippi’s Community Mental Health Centers filed against United Health Care of Mississippi over a rate-cut dispute.
Weeks, Inc. v. Lewis, 2020-IA-01337-SCT (Civil – Personal Injury/Venue)
Reversing the circuit court’s denial of the defendant’s motion to transfer venue, holding that venue based on a corporation’s principal place of business is determined by “the actual physical location” and expressly rejecting the plaintiff’s argument that venue was proper in a different county where the “principal address” listed in the defendant’s corporate filings with the Secretary of State is located.
(All justices concurred)
United Healthcare of Mississippi Inc. v. Mississippi’s Community Mental Health Commissions, 2020-CA-00697-SCT (Civil – Contract/Arbitration/Preliminary Injunction)
Affirming the circuit court’s ruling enjoining the Medicaid service provider from imposing a 5% rate cut and denying its motion to compel arbitration in a lawsuit filed by Mississippi’s Community Mental Health Centers (CMHC), holding (1) that trial courts have authority to enter preliminary injunctions even when there is an enforceable arbitration agreement, (2) that the record supported the trial court’s finding of a substantial likelihood that the service provider violated Miss. Code Ann. § 43-13-117(H)(1)(c) which governs Medicaid payment rates, and (3) that the trial court did not err in finding that the arbitration agreement was enforceable because it was not signed by a single CMHC board.
(All participating justices concurred; Justice Beam did not participate)
Other Orders
Golden v. State, 2019-CT-00757-SCT (denying cert petition)
M.A.S. v. Lamar County Department of Child Protective Services, 2020-CT-70-SCT (denying cert petition)
Alexander v. State, 2020-CT-177-SCT (denying cert petition)
Smith v. State, 202o-CT-580-SCT (denying cert petition and amended cert petition)
Gordon v. Dickerson, 2020-CT-601-SCT (granting cert petition)
Badger v. State, 2020-M-646 (denying “Motion to Reinvest Jurisdiction Into The Circuit Court of Amite County” and warning that future filings deemed frivolous may result not only in monetary sanctions, but also restrictions on filing applications for post-conviction collateral relief (or pleadings in that nature) in forma pauperis)
Mississippi Appeals Blog 