Hand Down Summaries – Page 11 – Mississippi Appeals Blog

Mississippi Court of Appeals Decisions of February 18, 2025

The Mississippi Court of Appeals handed down nine opinions today and one bonus opinion Thursday of last week. There are a few real property cases including a restrictive covenants case. There are two interesting speedy trial cases among several other direct criminal appeals.

February 13, 2025

Johnson v. Cleveland, 2023-CA-01011-COA (Civil – Real Property)
Reversing the chancery court’s decision in a tax sale and forfeited tax land patents, holding that a potential adverse possession claim did not confer standing, that the plaintiff lacked standing per section 29-1-21, and that the chancellor erred in declaring the tax sale void and ordering that the forfeited tax land patents be cancelled.
(6-4: Westbrooks dissented, joined by Barnes, McDonald, and Lawrence)

February 18, 2025

Wallace v. State, 2023-KA-00721-COA consolidated with 2023-KA-00723-COA, consolidated with 2023-KA-00888-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming convictions of three brothers who were tried together of capital murder, holding that the convictions were supported by sufficient evidence, that the trial court’s decision to allow an investigator to testify about a witness’s prior statement was harmless error, that the trial court did not in error for allowing testimony of prior bad acts to which there was no timely objection, that there was no violation of the constitutional right to a speedy trial under the totality of the circumstances, and that one brother’s ineffective assistance of counsel argument was without merit.
(7-3-0: Lawrence and McCarty concurred in part and in the result without writing; Westbrooks concurred in result only without writing)

Note – The speedy trial discussion is worth reading if that is in your wheelhouse.

1st Step Sober Living LLC v. Cleveland, 2023-CA-00665-COA (Civil – Other)
Affirming the chancellor’s decision granting residents’ request for injunctive relief preventing a home in a subdivision from being used by individuals recovering from substance abuse disorder, holding that the sale of the subject property did not render the case moot because damages were sought, that the proposed use was a commercial endeavor that was prohibited by restrictive covenants, and the chancellor did not err in determining that the rehab home did not sufficiently prove that the tenants would fit the “handicap” criteria for FHA purposes.
(10-0)

Brooks v. State, 2023-KA-01081-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of possession of a controlled substance and being a felon in possession of a firearm, holding that the evidence was sufficient to support both convictions.
(10-0)

Chambers v. State, 2023-KA-00626-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of one count of capital murder and two counts of felonious child abuse, holding that the trial court did not err in denying the defendant’s motion to suppress her statement to investigators where she voluntarily, knowingly, and intelligently waived her Miranda rights and that the State presented sufficient evidence for all convictions.
(9-1-0: Wilson concurred in part and in the result without writing)

LoanMax, LLC v. Castle Columbus I, LLC, 2023-CA-00790-COA (Civil – Contract)
Affirming in part and reversing in part the chancery court’s rulings in a claim for declaratory and injunctive relief involving a commercial lease renewal, holding on direct appeal that the chancellor did not err in finding that lessee did not provide notice required to effectively renew the lease, on cross-appeal that the chancellor did not err in finding that the owner is not entitled to damages for roofing or HVAC or to attorney’s fees, and on cross-appeal that the chancellor erred in her findings on holdover rent and remanded for a determination of what back rent may be owed.
(9-0: Barnes did not participate)

Taylor v. State, 2023-KA-00245-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon, holding that the defendant’s right to speedy trial was not violated.
(7-4*-0: McCarty specially concurred, joined by McDonald and St. Pe (who also joined the majority); Lawrence concurred in part and in the result without writing)

Note – The constitutional right to speedy trial got a lot of air time today. Here is how McCarty’s special concurrence on the subject kicks off:

Spearman v. State, 2023-KA-01091-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of aggravated assault, holding that there were no arguable issues for appeal after reviewing counsel’s Lindsey brief and the record.
(10-0)

Fears v. State, 2023-KA-00174-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of capital murder, armed robbery, conspiracy to commit armed robbery, and aggravated assault against victims responding to a fake Facebook Marketplace ad, holding that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying an accomplice jury instruction.
(10-0)

Johnson v. State, 2023-KA-00369-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming convictions of capital murder and felony child abuse, holding that the defendant abandoned his motion to server the counts against him when he failed to pursue a motion to hearing a decision and, further, that the trial court did not abuse its discretion denying the motion to sever.
(10-0)

Other Orders

Johnson v. SW Gaming, LLC, 2023-CA-00505-COA (denying rehearing)
Simmons v. State, 2023-KA-00518-COA (denying rehearing)

Hand Down Page – February 18, 2025

Hand Down Page – February 13, 2025

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of February 13, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down one opinion today. It is an uncommon interlocutory appeal in a felony case considering a double jeopardy argument.

Middleton v. State, 2024-IA-00144-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming the trial court’s denial of a motion to dismiss an indictment for felony possession of methamphetamine on the basis of double jeopardy, holding that the municipal court’s determination of the fine for possession of a controlled substance did not constitute a conviction for a possession of a controlled substance for double jeopardy to attach.
(9-0)

Other Orders

Estate of Warren: Warren v. Maharrey, 2023-CT-00438-SCT (denying cert)
In Re: Lonnie Coleman, 2024-M-00712 (granting mandamus and directing the trial court to enter rulings within 30 days)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Court of Appeals Decisions of February 11, 2025

The Mississippi Court of Appeals handed down five opinions today. Four are direct criminal appeals and the fifth is a PCR matter.

Luter v. State, 2023-KA-01305-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of manslaughter, holding that there was sufficient evidence to support the verdict and that the verdict was not against the overwhelming weight of the evidence.
(9-1-0: Westbrooks concurred in result only without writing)

Roberts v. State, 2023-CP-01387-COA (Civil – PCR)
Affirming denial of PCR motion because the arguments asserted on appeal were never presented to the trial court for review.
(10-0)

Turner v. State, 2023-KA-01167-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of trafficking a controlled substance and being a felon in possession of a firearm, holding that the State carried its burden of proving habitual offender status beyond a reasonable doubt and that the trial court did not err in denying a motion to suppress because the search was supported by probable cause.
(9-0: Weddle did not participate)

Mitchell v. State, 2023-KA-00764-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of aggravated assault and attempted aggravated assault, holding that there was sufficient evidence to support the conviction of aggravated assault, that the conviction of attempted aggravated assault was not against the overwhelming weight of the evidence, and that the trial court did not err in exclude evidence of the defendant’s alibi defense.
(10-0)

Jones v. State, 2023-KA-01164-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of first-degree murder, holding that the jury’s verdict was not against the overwhelming weight of the evidence.
(10-0)

Other Orders

Clemons v. State, 2022-CT-00700-COA (recalling mandate and granting pro se motion to stay mandate)
Short v. The Break Land Company, LLC, 2022-CA-01180-COA (denying rehearing)
Ramsey v. State, 2023-CP-00440-COA (granting pro se motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing and recalling mandate)
Miller v. State, 2023-CP-00813-COA (denying rehearing)
Haley v. State, 2024-TS-01165-COA (denying pro se motion for reinstatement of appeal and application for leave to proceed in forma pauperis)
Robinson v. State, 2024-TS-01286-COA (denying motion to proceed out of time)
Barnett v. State, 2024-TS-01298-COA (granting motion to proceed out of time)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of February 6, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down two opinions in direct criminal appeals today. The Court also issued five cert denials and granted a petition for interlocutory appeal in a premises case.

Broome v. State, 2023-KA-01163-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of aggravated assault, holding that an officer’s testimony about steps in the investigation was not hearsay, that it was improper hearsay for the officer to repeat a witness’s identification of the defendant but that it was harmless since that witness gave identification testimony at trial, and that an investigator’s lay testimony regarding the ultimate issue of fact was harmless if in error.
(7-2: Griffis concurred in part and dissented in part, joined by Sullivan)

Mackabee v. State, 2023-KA-00644-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of fourth-offense DUI, holding that there are no issues warranting appeal after reviewing counsel’s Lindsey brief and the record.
(9-0)

Other Orders

Smith v. State, 2019-DR-01492-SCT (denying motion for leave to file successive PCR motion)
Simmons v. State, 2023-CT-00130-SCT (denying cert)
Hyland v. State, 2023-CT-00256-SCT (denying cert)
Weeks. Weeks, 2023-CT-00427-SCT (denying cert)
Neal v. Cain, 2023-CT-00625-SCT (denying cert)
Davis v. State, 2023-CT-00663-SCT (denying cert)
Premier Entertainment Biloxi, LLC v. Ryan, 2024-IA-01175-SCT (granting interloc petition)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Court of Appeals Decisions of February 4, 2025

The Mississippi Court of Appeals handed down five opinions today: four direct criminal appeals and one PCR case. Three of the four criminal cases dealt with jury instruction issues.

Craft v. State, 2023-KA-00915-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction second-degree murder, holding that the verdict was supported by sufficient evidence, that the verdict was not against the overwhelming weight of the evidence, and that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in giving instructions on lesser-included offenses for which the defendant was not specifically indicted, and declining to address ineffective-assistance-of-counsel claims on direct appeal.
(8-1-0: Emfinger concurred in part and in result without writing; Carlton did not participate)

Hagan v. State, 2023-KA-00880-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of aggravated assault, holding that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in refusing the defendant’s lesser-included-offense jury instruction.
(10-0)

Wilson v. State, 2023-CP-01050-COA (Civil – PCR)
Affirming the trial court’s order denying a PCR motions and finding that they were frivolous, successive, time-barred, and barred by res judicata.
(10-0)

Jones v. State, 2022-KA-01124-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming convictions of first-degree murder and felon in possession, holding that the trial court did not err in refusing a heat-of-passion manslaughter instruction or a proposed instruction on the defense of necessity, and finding the pro se arguments that the indictment was insufficient, that habitual offender status was not proven beyond a reasonable doubt, and that the defendant’s Confrontation Clause rights were violated during the sentencing hearing lacked merit.
(8-1-0: McDonald concurs in result only without writing; Lawrence did not participate)

Johnson v. State, 2023-KA-00870-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of two counts of felon in possession of a firearm, holding that the second felon-in-possession count did not violate double jeopardy because the weapons were acquired at different times and the search and seizure of his the defendant’s vehicle were lawful.
(9-1: McDonald dissented without written opinion)

Other Orders

None

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of January 30, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down four opinions today. There was a UM dec action along with three direct criminal appeals. One of the direct criminal appeals resulted in reversal based on an erroneous jury instruction.

Williams v. Mississippi Farm Bureau Cas. Ins. Co., 2023-CA-01225-SCT (Civil – Insurance)
Affirming the trial court’s decision granting a UM carrier’s motion for summary judgment in a dec action, holding that the UM policy did not unlawfully restrict or reduce coverage mandated by Mississippi’s UM Act and that clear and unambiguous language in the policy excluded ATVs from the term “uninsured motorist.”
(9-0)

Barnett v. State, 2023-KA-00742-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Reversing conviction for sale of meth, holding that the trial court committed reversible error by giving a jury instruction that improperly commented on the weight of the evidence.
(7-2: Randolph dissented, joined by Branning)

N0te – Here is the text of the jury instruction that warranted reversal:

Robinson v. State, 2023-KA-00773-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of aggravated assault, holding that the evidence was sufficient to support the conviction, and rejecting the appellant’s pro se arguments that his appellate counsel were ineffective, that the State committed Brady violations, and that the trial court lacked jurisdiction.
(9-0)

Kendrick v. State, 2024-KM-00510-SCT (Criminal – Misdemeanor)
Affirming the circuit court’s decision affirming the county court’s decision affirming a municipal court conviction of DUI first offense and possession of drug paraphernalia, holding that the county court did not err in denying a motion to suppress that claimed the traffic stop was illegal.
(8-0: Randolph did not participate)

Other Orders

In Re: The Rules of Civil Procedure, 89-R-99001-SCT (granting motion to amend M.R.C.P. 14 to be effective 30 days from the entry of the order on January 27, 2025)
In Re: Weaver, 2017-M-00527 (denying misnamed application for leave to seek post-conviction relief in the trial court, finding the application successive and frivious, and warning that future frivolous filings may result in sanctions)
Lestrick v. State, 2021-CT-01409-SCT (dismissing cert petition)
Gilmer v. Biegel, 2022-CP-00528 (denying motion for citation of contempt and sanctions and ordering payment of sanction)
Weatherly v. Weatherly, 2022-CT-00804-SCT (granting cert)
Jackson v. State, 2023-CT-00201-SCT (denying cert)
Jackson v. State, 2023-CT_201-SCT (denying pro se cert petition)
Carpenter v. State, 2023-CT-00580-SCT (denying cert)CT (denying cert)
In Re Validation of up to $27,600,000 Trust Certificates Evidencing Proportional Interests in a Lease by The Simpson County School District: Floyd v. Simpson County School Board, 2023-CA-01126-SCT (denying motion for rehearing and amended motion for rehearing)
Parker v. Stewart, 2023-CA-01257-SCT (granting motion to dismiss appeal)
Parker v. Stewart, 2023-CA-01257 (per curiam affirmance)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Court of Appeals Decisions of January 28, 2025

The Mississippi Court of Appeals handed down four opinions yesterday and a stray opinion on Thursday of last week. Three are direct criminal appeals, one is a breach of contract/real property case, and the other is a PCR case.

Childs v. State, 2023-CA-00126-COA, consolidated with 2018-CT-00263-COA and 2011-CT-00263-COA (Civil – PCR)
Affirming denial of a motion for PCR, holding that it did not have subject matter over the venue claim, that there was no clear error in denying the Brady claim, and that the claimant failed to establish a claim of ineffective assistance.
(9-0: McCarty did not participate)

JLS Farm Partnership v. ’27 Break Hunting Club, Inc., 2023-CA-00434-COA (Civil – Contract)
Affirming the circuit court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of hunting clubs in a suit filed against them by an adjacent farming partnership after the partnership’s deer depredation permit was revoked and the clubs opposed a new permit, holding that the trial court did not err in finding no evidence to support the partnership’s claims of breach of contract, tortious breach of contract, breach of the implied duty of good faith and fair dealing, and promissory estoppel.
(9-0: Lawrence did not participate)

Haynes v. State, 2023-KA-00861-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Reversing conviction of manslaughter, holding that the trial court erred by denying a stand-your-ground instruction but also holding that the State presented sufficient evidence to sustain the conviction.
(9-1-0: Carlton concurred in result only without writing)

Adame v. State, 2023-KA-00758-COA (Criminal – Felony)
affirming conviction of fondling, holding that the trial court did not abuse its discretion by giving a jury instruction concerning uncorroborated testimony of a sex-crime victim.
(9-0: St. Pe’ did not participate)

Note – Here is the jury instruction that passed muster:

Bonus decision from January 23, 2025

Culbertson v. State, 2023-KA-00588-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of two counts of aggravated domestic violence as a violent habitual offender, holding that the trial court did not err in refusing a lesser-included offense instruction for each count, in denying a motion to exclude evidence of the defendant’s prior bad acts, or in sentencing him as a habitual offender, and that trial counsel was not ineffective for not submitting a lesser-included instruction that was not warranted.
(5-5: Barnes concurred in part and dissented in part, joined by Wilson, Westbrooks, McDonald, and Emfinger)

Other Orders

Mazie v. Boozier-Mazie, 2023-CA-00470-COA (denying rehearing)
Walker v. State, 2023-CP-00787-COA (denying rehearing)

Hand Down Page – Jan. 28, 2025

Hand Down Page – Jan. 23, 2025

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of January 23, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down two decisions today. One in an interlocutory appeal of a denial of a motion to dismiss a 1983/HIPAA suit against a hospital and the other is a termination of parental right case.

Greenwood Leflore Hospital v. Boykin, 2023-IA-00820-SCT (Civil – Other)
Reversing the trial court’s denial of the hospital’s motion to dismiss a § 1983 suit alleging that the hospital intentionally withheld the plaintiff’s medical records which in turn deprived her of access to courts by preventing her from filing a med mal suit, holding that the plaintiff’s failure to file a brief constituted a confession of reversible error and then addressing the merits and holding that the plaintiff could not use § 1983 to enforce a federal statute (HIPAA) that does not give her an individual right.
(7-2-0: Coleman concurred in part and in the result; Randolph concurred in result only)

Practice Point – File a brief.

Note – Justice Coleman’s short concurrence took issue with the Court’s decision to address the merits after finding that the failure to file a brief constituted confession of reversible error. I thought this concurrence was interesting in light of appellate courts’ occasional habit of deciding that arguments “also meritless” after deciding dispositive issues that do not reach the merits such as an argument is waived or time-barred. Here is the concurrence:

X.G.C. v. Jackson County Department of Child Protection Services, 2023-CA-00138-SCT (Civil – Custody)
Affirming the chancellor’s decision terminating parental rights, holding that the court did not err in terminating parental rights and that the record supported the Court’s finding that the statutory requirements of § 93-15-115 and § 93-14-119 were satisfied.
(9-0)

Other Orders

Black v. State, 2022-CT-01223-SCT (denying cert)
Sinquefield v. City of Ridgeland, 2022-CT-01276-SCT (denying cert)
Carr v. State, 2023-DR-00503-SCT (staying matter until April 16, 2025, to allow the State to return to the United States District Court for the Northern District of Mississippi and move to lift the stay and for any other appropriate relief)
Haley v. Brewer, 2023-CT-00571-SCT (denying cert)
McGee v. McGee, 2023-CA-00695-SCT (denying rehearing)
In Re: Administrative Orders of the Supreme Court of Mississippi, 2025-AD-00001-SCT (directing the disbursement of $213,407.18 in civil legal assistance funds among the MS Center for Legal Services, MS Volunteer Lawyers Project, and North MS Rural Legal Services)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Court of Appeals Decisions of January 21, 2025

The Mississippi Court of Appeals handed down six opinions today. There is a pair of direct criminal appeals, a pair of PCR decisions, a custody decision, and an adverse possession decision.

Burnette v. State, 2023-CP-01330-COA (Civil – PCR)
Affirming summary dismissal of PCR motion, holding that it was time-barred.
(9-0: St. Pe’ did not participate)

Moore v. State, 2024-CP-00150-COA (Civil – PCR)
Affirming summary dismissal of a PCR motion, holding that it was time-barred and successive.
(9-0: St. Pe’ did not participate)

Grimes v. State, 2023-KA-01254-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of manslaughter and sentence after remand for an evidentiary hearing on alleged juror misconduct, holding that the trial court did not err in finding that no conduct by a juror prejudiced the defendant.
(8-0: Weddle and St. Pe’ did not participate)

Adams v. Adams, 2023-CA-01041-COA (Civil – Domestic Relations)
Affirming the chancellor’s custody ruling in a divorce proceeding, holding that the chancellor did not err in applying the Albright factors and determining that it was in the children’s best interest to award sole physical custody to the mother.
(9-0: St. Pe’ did not participate)

Robinson v. State, 2023-KA-00575-COA (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of sexual battery, holding that in light of overwhelming evidence of guilt the defendant failed to show that his trial counsel was ineffective for introducing a recording between an officer and a witness.
(7-2-0: Barnes concurred in part and in the result without writing; Wilson concurred in result only without writing; St. Pe’ did not participate)

Phillips v. Forrest County Industrial Park Commission, 2023-CA-01132-COA (Civil – Real Property)
Affirming the chancellor’s finding that the Commission acquired title to two acres of land by adverse possession and dismissing counterclaims, holding that the Commission proved the elements of adverse possession and that as a result the appellants’ counterclaims for trespass, unlawful withholding possession, and unjust enrichment were properly dismissed.
(6-3-0: Wilson and McDonald concurred in part and in the result without writing; Westbrooks concurred in result only without writing)

Other Orders

None

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of January 16, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down two opinions today. One is a termination of parental rights decision and the other a judicial performance case against Carlos Moore.

J.J.B. v. Monroe County Department of Child Protective Services, 2023-CA-00532-SCT (Civil – Custody)
Affirming the chancellor’s decision in a custody matter, holding that the chancellor did not err in terminating the mother’s parental rights where even after CPS took the children into custody the mother failed to comply with a service plan for reunification and an agreed court order.
(9-0)

Mississippi Commission on Judicial Performance v. Moore, 2024-JP-00121-SCT (Civil – Judicial Performance)
Finding that a municipal court judge’s social media posts and public comments violated the Mississippi Constitution, the canons of judicial conduct, and a memorandum of understanding between the Commission and the judge, resulting in removal from the bench and a $3,000 fine.
(8-1: King dissented, arguing that the statements at issue were protected by the First Amendment)

NOTE – Here are the two allegations of misconduct at issue. First, comments made on the Kelly Clarkson Show:

Second, a social media commentary on the Kyle Rittenhouse trial:

Hand Down Page