Category: Supreme Court

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of May 25, 2023

It was a slow day at the Mississippi Supreme Court for the hand-down department. The Court handed down just one opinion in a DOR case about unpaid sales tax and denied cert in two other cases.

Saltwater Sportsman Outfitters, LLC v. Mississippi Dept. of Revenue, 2021-SA-00881-SCT (Civil – State Boards & Agencies)
Affirming summary judgment in favor of MDOR in a dispute over unpaid sales taxes, holding that the company’s failure to keep records rendered MDOR’s assessment presumptively correct and that the company could not overcome that presumption.
(9-0)

Blount v. State, 2021-CT-00204-SCT (denying cert)

Moss v. Moss, 2021-CT-00452-SCT (denying cert)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of May 18, 2023

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down four opinions today. Three are direct criminal appeals and one is an interlocutory appeal of a tort suit that a litigant filed against counsel for the opposing party. One of the criminal cases was taken up so the Supreme Court could address for the first time the issue of whether the crime of attempted murder requires an “overt act” under the amended 97-1-7. The Supreme Court also granted cert in a child custody modification case.

Anderson v. State, 2022-KA-00530-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of first-degree murder and life sentence, holding that the trial court did not err in refusing a heat-of-passion instruction or in allowing the defendant’s confession to be presented to the jury, and that the verdict was supported by sufficient evidence and not against the overwhelming weight of it.
(9-0)

Beale v. State, 2020-CT-00614-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of attempted murder on cert, holding that the indictment correctly stated the necessary elements of the crime and that two jury instructions did not constructively amend the indictment.
(6-3: King dissented, joined by Kitchens and Coleman.)

NOTE – The Mississippi Supreme Court granted cert to address for the first time the issue of whether the crime of attempted murder requires an “overt act” under the amended Miss. Code Ann. § 97-1-7:

Henley, Lotterhos & Henley, PLLC v. Bryant, 2021-IA-00994-SCT (Civil – Torts)
Reversing the circuit court’s denial of a law firm’s motion to dismiss/summary judgment in a lawsuit asserting a slew of intentional torts stemming from the handing of a subrogation claim, holding that attorneys do not owe duties to adverse parties that can give rise to tort liability and remanding for litigation of the claims against the insurance company.
(5-2-1: Randolph and Griffis concurred in result only without separate written opinion; King dissented; Kitchens did not participate.)

Spiers v. State, 2022-KA-00038-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of burglary of a dwelling and attempted sexual battery, holding that the defendant waived the issue of whether the trial court erred by granting a jury instruction requiring the defendant to prove consent by clear and convincing evidence and that the plain error doctrine did not apply, that the defendant failed to establish a case of ineffective assistance as to the instruction, and that the trial court did not commit plain error with regard to alleged prosecutorial misconduct during closing.
(5-1-3: Maxwell concurred in part and in result without separate written opinion; King dissented, joined by Kitchens and Coleman)

Other Orders

Price v. State, 2019-CT–01890-SCT (denying cert)

Blagodirova v. Schrock, 2020-CT-01162-SCT (granting cert) (You can read my summary of the 4-2-4 COA decision by clicking here.)

Davis v. Davis, 2020-CA-01304-SCT (denying rehearing)

Bowman v. State, 2020-CT-01371-COA (denying cert)

Tennesen v. City of Hattiesburg, 2021-CT-00137-SCT (denying cert)

Hand Down List

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of May 11, 2023

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down four decisions today. One is an interlocutory appeal of a discovery order in a personal injury case and one is a direct criminal appeal. The other two are election contest cases, one regarding the race for public service commissioner and other a state representative race.

Mississippi Baptist Health Systems, Inc. v. Johnson, 2022-IA-00158-SCT (Civil – Personal Injury)
Reversing the trial court’s order compelling the defendant hospital to produce two incident reports over a claim of privilege, holding that the trial court erred in ordering production without conducting in camera review and remanding for that purpose.
(9-0)

Norwood v. State, 2021-KA-00903-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of aggravated domestic violence, holding that there was no reasonable probability that, but for defense counsel’s failure to present evidence of the victim’s purported drug use while cross-examining her, the trial result would have been different.
(9-0)

Gunasekara v. Barton, 2023-EC-00377-SCT (Civil – Election Contest)
Affirming the trial court’s decision in an election contest, holding that the trial court did not manifestly err by holding that the plaintiff failed to meet the five-year residency requirements for the office of Public Service Commissioner.
(6-0: Coleman, Maxwell, and Chamberlin did not participate.)

NOTE – The Court declined to address the plaintiff’s claim that the five-year citizenship requirement violated the 14th Amendment, noting that the Attorney General should be given the opportunity to argue the question of constitutionality.

Jones v. Yates, 2023-EC-00395-SCT (Civil – Election Contest)
Affirming the trial court’s finding in an election contest, holding that the trial court erred in determining that the would-be candidate for state representative satisfied the two-year residency requirement but affirmed because the trial court reached the correct outcome for other reasons.
(9-0)

Other Orders

Short v. State, 2021-CT-00499-SCT (dismissing pro se cert petition)

Davis v. State, 2021-CT-00593-SCT (denying cert)

Meek v. Cheyenne Steel, Inc., 2021-CT-01219-SCT (denying cert)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of May 4, 2023

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down three opinions today. One involves where an employee of a police department was entitled to a probable cause hearing, another is a trusts decision on cert that turned on the validity of statute of limitations arguments made for the first time on appeal, and the third is an intentional tort/First Amendment case stemming from a case that was the subject of a popular podcast. The Supreme Court also granted cert in one case.

Wallace v. State, 2022-CA-00119-SCT (Civil – Other)
Affirming the circuit court’s decision denying a probable cause hearing after a police department employee was charged with simple assault of a minor, holding that a law enforcement officer who is not certified under section 45-6-11(3)(a) is not entitled to a probable cause hearing under section 99-3-28(1)(a)(i) and that the defendant was not entitled to a probable cause hearing because he was not within the scope of section 45-6-3(c).
(9-0)

Parker v. Ross, 2020-CT-01055-SCT (Civil – Wills, Trusts & Estates)
Affirming in part and reversing in part the Court of Appeals in a trusts case, holding (1) the trial court did not err by granting a motion to dismissed based on the three-year statute of limitations and that the Court of Appeals erred by reversing that decision based on the ten-year statute of limitations that was raised for the first time on appeal and (2) that the trial court did err in finding that the statute of limitations was not tolled due to disability, affirming the Court of Appeals’ reversal based on sufficiency of evidence of disability.
(8-0: Kitchens did not participate.)

Wagner v. Andreacchio, 2021-IA-01199-SCT (Civil – Torts)
Reversing the trial court’s denial of the defendant’s motion to dismiss claims of intentional infliction of emotional distress, gross negligence, invasion of privacy, and civil conspiracy stemming from the defendant’s publication of portions of an investigative file related to the plaintiffs’ son’s death, holding that the defendant’s publication of public records is constitutionally-protected speech.
(8-1: Griffis dissented)

NOTE – This is the case stems from the death of Christian Andreacchio that was the subject of the first season of the Culpable podcast.

Other Orders

In Re: State Intervention Courts Advisory Committee, 89-R-99039-SCT (appointing or reappointing E. Gregory Snowden, Director of the Administrative Office of the Courts, as Chair of the State Intervention Courts Advisory Committee and the following as members through December 31, 2023: Judge Michael M. Taylor, Judge Winston L. Kidd, Judge Robert Helfrich, Judge Charles E. Webster, Judge Kathy King Jackson, Melody Madaris, Representative Angela Cockerham, Mark Smith, Judge Randi P. Mueller, and Nathan Blevins)

Dampier v. State, 2021-CT-00280-SCT (granting cert)

Scruggs v. Farmland Mutual Insurance Company, 2021-CA-00877-SCT (denying rehearing)

Jarvis v. State, 2021-CT-00930-SCT (denying cert)

Wallace v. State, 2021-CT-01149-SCT (denying cert)

Keys v. Rehabilitation, Inc., 2021-CT-01338-SCT (denying cert)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of April 27, 2023

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down two opinions today. Both decisions are 6-3 reversals. One is an appeal of a summary judgment ruling in a slip-and-fall case and the other is an appeal of a zoning decision.

Thomas v. Boyd Biloxi, LLC, 2021-CT-00265-SCT (Civil – Personal Injury)
Reversing the COA’s decision affirming summary judgment in favor of a resort in a slip-and-fall on a pool deck case, holding that two prior falls and evidence that water pooled in the area where the plaintiff fell was sufficient evidence of breach and that there was evidence that a breach of duty proximately caused the fall.
(6-3: Griffis dissented, joined by Coleman and Ishee.)

City of Ocean Springs v. Illanne, 2021-CA-01100-SCT (Civil – State Boards and Agencies)
Reversing the circuit court’s reversal of a City’s zoning decisions, holding that remand was necessary for a hearing to determine whether a zoning applicant was a “petitioner” under Section 11-51-75 such that the failure to name him and give him notice deprived the circuit court of jurisdiction.
(6-3: Coleman dissented, joined by Randolph and Griffis)

Other Order

La Casa I, LLC v. Gottfried, 2021-CT-00347-SCT (denying cert)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of April 20, 2023

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down four opinions today. There is one med mal case that is a civil procedure/amendment case. There is a decision addressing the application of the “malicious conduct” exception to the peer review and quality assurance privileges. There is also a direct criminal appeal and a foreclosure case. There were also two interesting cert grants.

Franklin County Memorial Hospital v. Fairman, 2021-IA-01283-SCT (Civil – Medical Malpractice)
Affirming denial of a motion to dismiss on statute of limitations grounds, holding that Rule 21 does not require a court order when an amended complaint could otherwise be filed as a matter of course and the amendment merely corrects the misidentification of a defendant and that such an amendment relates back to the date of initial filing.
(9-0)

Rush v. Rush Health Systems, Inc., 2020-IA-01116-SCT (Civil – Contract)
Dismissing and remanding after receiving the trial court’s discovery order entered in response to a prior remand, addressing only a question of law and adopting a standard to determine when a physician is entitled to production of information protected by Sections 41-63-9, -23, and -45 under the malicious conduct exception.
(9-0)

NOTE – Here is the standard in all its glory:

Eaton v. State, 2021-KA-01334-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of second-degree murder and aggravated assault, holding that the trial court did not err in admitting a glass pipe into evidence and that the convictions were supported by sufficient evidence and not against the overwhelming weight of it.
(9-0)

WBL SPO I, LLC v. West Town Bank & Trust, 2021-CA-00792-SCT (Civil – Other)
Affirming on direct appeal and cross appeal, holding that a junior creditor had no legal remedy entitling it to “equitable credit” in the form of money damages from the foreclosing creditor in the amount of the difference in the foreclosing creditor’s purchase price and the alleged market value of the property and the dismissal of the foreclosing creditor’s counterclaim for tortious interference with business relations.
(5-4-0: Kitchens concurred in result only, joined by Randolph, King, and Chamberlin)

PRACTICE POINT – You can’t appeal without a ruling, and it’s your job to secure a ruling:

Other Orders

In Re: Mississippi Rules of Criminal Procedure, 89-R-99038-SCT (denying motion to amend Miss. R. Crim. P. 5 and 8 but amending the Miss. R. Crim. P. on the Court’s own motion)

In Re: Administrative Orders of the Supreme Court of Mississippi, 2023-AD-00001-SCT (order directing the disbursement of $189,074.60 in civil legal assistance funds among the MS Center for Legal Services, MS Volunteer Lawyers Project, and North MS Rural Legal Services)

Rush v. Rush Health Systems, Inc., 2020-IA-01116-SCT (denying motion to supplement the record and motion to file exhibits under seal)

Howard Industries, Inc. v. Hayes, 2021-CT-00694-SCT (granting cert)
NOTE – Here is my summary of the 5-4 COA opinion (Wilson wrote the partial dissent).

Loblolly Properties LLC v. Le Papillon Homeowner’s Association Inc., 2021-CT-00767-SCT (granting cert)
NOTE – This is a case I had put on “cert watch” when a fractured COA (3-3-4) affirmed the lower court and a Wilson-penned dissent raised some big issues. Here is my summary of the COA opinion.

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of April 13, 2023

I was out of town Thursday and Friday doing fun things with my family and summarizing hand downs didn’t fit the agenda. Without further delay, here are summaries of the four decisions the Mississippi Supreme Court handed down while I was out. There is a wrongful death/premises liability decision, a direct appeal of a murder conviction, and two real property contract decisions.

Deepak Jasco, LLC v. Palmer, 2021-IA-00702-SCT (Civil – Wrongful Death)
Reversing the denial of summary judgment in a premises liability case, holding that the plaintiff did not prove that the owner and operator of a convenience store adjacent to a lot where the plaintiff’s decedent was found stabbed and killed had actual or constructive knowledge that an atmosphere of violence existed on the premises.
(5-4-0: Maxwell concurred in part and in the result, joined by Randolph and Beam)

NOTE – Here is the crux of the Court’s analysis:

Anderson v. State, 2022-KA-00007-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of murder, holding that the trial court did not err by refusing an excusable homicide instruction based on heat of passion or by admitting evidence of the defendant’s prior bad act of using methamphetamine just before the shooting and for several days before where the defendant himself testified that he was high on meth when he shot his grandmother and it was relevant to his state of mind and motive.
(9-0)

Sel Business Services, LLC v. Lord, 2021-CT-00368-SCT (Civil – Real Property)
Affirming in part and reversing in part the chancellor’s grant of summary judgment in favor of a property owner who made an oral agreement to sell to one buyer but then sold to someone else, holding that while the statute of frauds barred the claim for specific performance the would-be buyer still had other equitable remedies available.
(9-0)

NOTE – The decisions specifically overruled Barriffe v. Estate of Nelson, 153 So. 3d 613 (Miss. 2014):

Luxe Homes, LLC v. Brewer, 2022-IA-00132-SCT (Civil – Contract)
Reversing the chancellor’s denial of a motion to transfer venue, holding that the terms of a venue provision in the contract between the parties were unambiguous, mandatory, and enforceable and that the transferred to the circuit court of the venue county even though the suit sought specific performance of a real estate contract.
(7-2-0: Kitchens and King concurred in result only without separate written opinion)

Other Orders

$153,340 v. State, 2020-CT-01409-SCT (cert denied)

Wilson v. City of Greenville, 2021-CT-00316-SCT (cert denied)

Johnson v. State, 2021-CT-00571-SCT (cert denied)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of April 6, 2023

I am circling back to pick up the rest of the hand downs that I missed last week. The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down six opinions last Thursday with a couple of reversals. There were two skirmishes in med mal cases, one involved an arbitration agreement and the other the substitution of the administrator of an estate. There is a UM case about the right to UM benefits after cutting off the carrier’s subrogation rights. There is also a sixteenth section land case and what should have been an MTCA case. The Supreme Court also denied a petition for reinstatement to the practice of law.

Mississippi Farm Bureau Cas. Ins. Co. v. Peteet, 2021-IA-01420-SCT (Civil – Insurance)
Reversing the denial of a motion to dismiss by a UM carrier, holding that the insured’s execution of a settlement agreement with the at-fault driver unlawfully cut off the UM carrier’s right of subrogation and the UM carrier therefore had no duty to pay the UM claim.
(9-0)

Sill v. State, 2021-KA-00317-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of possession of meth, holding that the trial court did not err in denying the defendant’s motion to suppress evidence found in his car because the defendant did not prove that he had a legitimate expectation of privacy in a stolen vehicle, that the State met its burden to prove construction possession, and that the jury could reasonable infer that the untested substance was of the same substance as what was tested.
(9-0)

Belhaven Senior Care, LLC v. Smith, 2022-CA-00050-SCT (Civil – Contract)
Affirming denial of a motion to compel arbitration, holding that the facility failed to prove that the signatory of the arbitration agreement was the resident’s healthcare surrogate, that the plaintiff was not barred by direct-benefit estoppel from contesting the validity of the arbitration agreement, and that the decdent was not a third-party beneficiary of the agreement.
(9-0)

North Bolivar Consolidated Sch. Dist. v. Jones, 2021-IA-01235-SCT (Civil – Real Property)
Reversing the denial of the school district’s motion for summary judgment, holding that the school district’s past acceptance of late rent payments for sixteenth section land were not authorized and could not form the basis of estoppel that would prevent the school district from assessing statutory late-payment penalties.
(9-0)

Morton v. City of Clarksdale, 2022-CA-00216-SCT (Civil – Torts)
Affirming the dismissal of claims that an arrest violated constitutional rights, holding that most of the plaintiff’s claims fell under the MTCA and were barred by the MTCA’s one-year statute of limitations, that the constitutional claims were barred by the three-year statute of limitations, and that the malicious prosecution claim was barred by the one-year statute of limitations for such claims.
(9-0)

Otuseso v. Estate of Mason, 2021-IA-01099-SCT (Civil – Wills, Trusts and Estates)
Affirming the chancellor’s decision removing the administratrix of an estate who had filed a wrongful death suit against a doctor on behalf of the estate and substituting two heirs-at-law as coadminstrators, holding that the doctor’s motion to intervene in the chancery court proceedings was moot since the chancellor had properly removed the unqualified administrator and appointed successor administrators.
(9-0)

Other Orders

Stewart v. The Mississippi Bar, 2022-BR-00382-SCT (denying fourth petition for reinstatement to the practice of law)

Virden v. Campbell Delong, LLC, 2021-CT-00478-SCT (granting cert)
I put this on the “cert watch” list when the COA opinion was handed down. It is a lawyer fight over money with a 5-5 COA decision that left the trial court’s ruling in place. (My summary of the COA decision is here.)

Hand Down List

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of March 30, 2023

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down one opinion today in a criminal case along with one disbarment.

Willard v. State, 2022-KA-00339-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of possession of meth and sentencing as a habitual offender, holding that the trial court did not clearly err by striking two members of the venire for cause and that any error committed by sustaining the State’s objection to continuing a line of questioning on the contents of a hearsay report not prepared by the witness was harmless.
(9-0)

NOTE – The two potential jurors were struck for cause as a result of saying they were unwilling to convict on the testimony of a law enforcement officer alone.

Other Orders

Mississippi Bar v. Patrick, 2022-BD-01093-SCT (disbarring attorney in lieu of requested indefinite suspension)

Howell v. State, 2020-CA-00868-SCT (denying rehearing)

Hand Down List