Category: Supreme Court

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of August 21, August 28, and September 4

I have been swamped the last few weeks and find myself behind on summaries. One contributing factor is that my firm, Wilkins Patterson, relocated at the end of August. In one form or another, the firm has resided at One LeFleur’s Square on Old Canton Road in Jackson for decades. That location served the firm well, and it was not left without a heap of nostalgia and a tinge of sadness. But as Bob Dylan reminds us, “He not busy being born is busy dying.” This move marks an exciting chapter of growth and opportunity for the firm that we are immensely thankful for. You can find us at 690 Towne Center Boulevard in Ridgeland.

With this post, we are caught up on Mississippi Supreme Court decisions. We may not ever catch up on the Court of Appeals decisions from the past three weeks. This is due, in part, to the fact that over that period of time the Court of Appeals handed down twenty opinions and the Supreme Court handed down four. If you are so inclined, you can follow these links to the COA hand downs: August 19, August 26, and September 2. Read on for Supreme Court decisions…

August 21, 2025

No Opinions

Other Orders

  • Parker v. State, 2023-CT-00550-SCT (denying cert)
  • Mount v. State, 2023-CT-00807-SCT (denying cert)
  • Turner v. State, 2023-CT-01167-SCT (denying cert)
  • Lynch v. State, 2024-M-01275 (finding that the application for leave to proceed in the trial court was frivolous and warning that future frivolous filings may result in sanctions)
  • Priority One Bank v. Hall, 2025-IA-00939-SCT (granting emergency petition for interlocutory appeal)

Hand Down Page

August 28, 2025

Reyes v. State, 2024-KA-00590-SCT (Criminal- Felony)
Affirming conviction of capital murder and life sentence, holding that the trial court did not err in denying the defendant’s motion suppress statements he made to law enforcement, that the State did not vouch for a witness’s credibility, that the issue of whether it was error to allow the State to play portions of a witness’s interview with law enforcement was procedurally barred, and that the ineffective-assistance-of-counsel arguments did not require reversal.
(9-0: Griffis for the Court)

Busby Outdoor LLC v. Ditto, 2024-IA-00209-SCT, consolidated with No. 2024-CA-00258-SCT (Civil – Other)
Reversing the chancery court’s injunction enforcing the City’s sign ordinance on a billboard situated on state-owned land, holding that “[t]he zoning ordinances must yield in this case to state sovereignty.”
(9-0: King for the Court)

Note – I thought for a moment that the Mississippi Supreme Court was about to tackle some big theological issues.

Though it passed on the issue of God’s sovereignty, the Court did hold in this case that that the created could not regulate its creator.

Other Orders

  • Sims v. State, 2017-M-01379 (finding that the application for leave to proceed in the trial court was frivolous and warning that future frivolous filings may result in sanctions)
  • Chamberlin v. State, 2022-DR-00546-SCT (granting cert)
  • Boone v. State, 2023-CT-00684-SCT (denying cert)
  • Burnette v. State, 2023-SCT-01330-SCT (denying cert)

Hand Down Page

September 4, 2025

Smith v. State, 2024-KA-00675-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of aggravated assault, holding that the trial court did not err in admitting lay opinion testimony from the victim’s treating physicians and that trial counsel was not ineffective for failing to object to that testimony.
(9-0: Chamberlin for the Court)

Sunshine Mills, Inc. v. Nutra-Blend, LLC, 2023-CA-01208-SCT (Civil – Torts)
Reversing the trial court’s grant of summary judgment for the defendant, holding that the Mississippi Products Liability Act did not govern the claims for breach of contract and implied warranty because they sounded in contract and did not allege damage stemming from a defective product.
(9-1-0: Coleman for the Court; Randolph concurred in the result only without writing)

Other Orders

  • In Re: Rules of Discipline for the Mississippi Bar,  89-R-99010-SCT (appointing or reappointing Hon. Haydn J. Roberts, John G. Holaday, Amy K. Taylor, Hon. Jennifer T. Schloegel, David A. Pumford, Jeremy T. England, Hon. Kelly D. Mims, Jason D. Herring, and Rachel Pierce Waide to three-year terms (9/01/25 to 8/31/28) as members of the Complaint Tribunals.)
  • In Re: Commission on Continuing Legal Education, 89-R-99011-SCT (denying Petition of the Mississippi Commission on Continuing Legal Education to Amend Rule 1(d) of the Rules and Regulations for Mandatory Continuing Legal Education)
  • In Re: Rules Governing Admission to The Mississippi Bar, 89-R-99012-SCT (reappointing Pieter Teeuwissen, Marcie Fyke Baria, and Gwendolyn Baptist-Rucker to three-year terms (11/1/25 through 10/31/28) as members of the Mississippi Board of Bar Admissions)
  • Weatherly v. Weatherly, 2022-CT-00804-SCT (dismissing cert)
  • Star v. State, 2023-CT-00788-SCT (denying cert)
  • Haynes v. State, 2023-CT-00861-SCT (denying cert)
  • Brown v. Madison County Board of Supervisors, 2024-EC-01059-SCT (denying rehearing)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of August 14, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down three opinions yesterday. I can report that the “minutes rule” is alive and well and is not to be trifled with.

But before we jump into summaries, I should acknowledge that the biggest appellate news in Mississippi this week is the appointments of Justice Maxwell and Justice Chamberlin to the United States District Court for the Northern District of Mississippi. If they are confirmed, that will create two vacancies in the Supreme Court District 3. That district is comprised of Alcorn, Attala, Benton, Calhoun, Carroll, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Clay, Coahoma, Desoto, Grenada, Itawamba, Lafayette, Lee, Leflore, Lowndes, Marshall, Monroe, Montgomery, Oktibbeha, Panola, Pontotoc, Prentiss, Quitman, Tallahatchie, Tate, Tippah, Tishomingo, Tunica, Union, Webster, Winston, and Yalobusha Counties.

Since two new justices (Branning and Sullivan) joined the Mississippi Supreme Court this year, we could have four justices joining the nine-justice court within a year. This has court-reshaping potential and will be an interesting process to watch.

K.S. v. M.D., 2023-CA-01118-SCT, consolidated with No. 2024-CA-00707-SCT (Civil – Custody)
Affirming the chancellor’s decision terminating parental rights and denying a Rule 60(b) motion to set aside adoption, holding that the chancellor had jurisdiction to terminate parental rights and that the chancellor did not abuse his discretion in terminating parental rights, and that as a result the adoption did not have to be vacated for lack of jurisdiction.
(9-0: Ishee for the Court)

The Mississippi State Port Authority at Gulfport v. Yilport Holding A.S., 2024-IA-00140-SCT, consolidated with No. 2024-IA-00149-SCT (Civil – State Boards & Agencies)
Affirming in part and reversing in part the circuit court’s rulings in a case following failed negotiations after a letter of intent was signed concerning a port expansion, holding that the trial court did not err in applying the “minutes rule” and finding that the LOI was not properly spread upon the minutes of the board and was therefore unenforceable, that estoppel did not apply, that the circuit court did err in allowing the unjust enrichment claim to go forward, and that the trial court did not err in denying summary judgment on the misappropriation-of-trade-secrets claim under the MTCA.
(9-0: King for the Court)

Sardin v. State, 2024-KA-00319-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of trafficking a controlled substance, holding that there were no arguable issues after reviewing counsel’s Lindsey brief and the record.
(9-0: Randolph for the Court)

Other Orders

  • In Re: the Rules of Civil Procedure, 89-R-99001-SCT (granting motion to amend M.R.C.P. 3)
  • In Re: Commission on Continuing Legal Education, 89-R-99011-SCT (appointing Helen Morris, Amanda B. Seymour, and Katherine K. Farese to three-year terms as members of the Commission on Continuing Legal Education)
  • Frazier v. State, 2016-M-01363 (denying motion for reconsideration of denial of motion to recuse)
  • Armistad v. State, 2023-CT-00799-SCT (denying cert)
  • Young v. Martin, 2023-CT-00980-SCT (denying cert)
  • Doby v. South Park Village Apartments, 2023-CA-01095-SCT (denying rehearing)
  • Phillips v. State, 2023-KA-01218-SCT (denying cert)
  • Tucker v. State, 2024-KA-00255-SCT (dismissing appeal as moot)
  • Mississippi Methodist Hospital & Rehabilitation Center, Inc. v. Mississippi Department of Health, 2925-SA-01113-SCT (denying motion to award costs and attorneys’ fees)
  • Rogers v. The Mississippi Bar, 2025-BD-00833-SCT (accepting irrevocable resignation as a member of the Mississippi Bar, tendered under Rule 11(a) of the Rules of Discipline for the Mississippi Bar)

Hand Down Page

Double Issue: Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of July 31, 2025 and August 7, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down one opinion last week and one this week. Both were direct criminal appeals, but this week’s decision is a death penalty case. You can read about them below.

July 31, 2025

Harrelson v. State, 2024-KA-00600-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of statutory rape, holding that the defendant was not deprived of a fair trial by improper comments by the State because there was no objection at trial and there was substantial evidence of guilt, and holding that the verdict was not against the overwhelming weight of the evidence.
(9-0: Chamberlin for the Court)

Other Orders

  • Miller v. State, 2023-CA-00322-SCT (denying cert)
  • United Emergency Services of Mississippi, Inc. v. Miller, 2023-IA-00767-SCT (denying rehearing)
  • J.S. v. Ocean Springs School District, 2023-CA-01009-SCT (denying rehearing)
  • Tubbs v. State, 2023-KA-01124-SCT (denying rehearing)
  • In Re: Administrative Orders of the Supreme Court of Mississippi, 2025-AD-00001-SCT (directing the disbursement of $216,005.10, in civil legal assistance funds among the MS Center for Legal Services, MS Volunteer Lawyers Project, and North MS Rural Legal Services)
  • Liberty Mutual Insurance Company v. Body, 2025-IA-00510-SCT (granting interloc)

Hand Down Page

August 7, 2025

Abram v. State, 2023-DP-00614-SCT (Criminal – Death Penalty)
Affirming conviction of two counts of capital murder and one count of attempted murder and his death sentence, holding that the circuit court did not abuse its discretion by admitting evidence from locations other than the crime scene, that the evidence was sufficient to support the capital murder convictions, and that the capital-murder convictions were not against the overwhelming weight of the evidence, and declining to abandon the M’Naghten Rule.
(9-0: Ishee for the Court)

Other Orders

  • Nailer v. State, 2023-CA-00627-SCT (denying cert)
  • Estate of Roberts: Herd v. Stokes, 2023-CT-00713-SCT (denying cert)
  • Gardner v. State, 2023-CT-00903-SCT (granting cert)
  • Wilson v. State, 2023-CT-01050-SCT (denying cert)
  • Grimes v. State, 2023-CT-01254-SCT (denying cert)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of June 19 and June 26, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down two opinions last week and three this week. Among them, two election contests, a death penalty PCR case that was remanded, an MTCA personal injury case on interlocutory appeal, and a felony conviction.

June 19, 2025

Brown v. Madison County Board of Supervisors, 2024-EC-01059-SCT (Civil – Election Contest)
Affirming the circuit court’s decision in an election contest, holding that the circuit court did not err in denying a motion to disqualify the Board’s attorney and in affirming the Board’s decision approving the candidate’s candidacy.
(9-0: Randolph for the Court)

Clark v. State, 2022-DR-00829-SCT (Civil – Death Penalty – PCR)
Granting motion for PCR in a death-penalty case, holding that the case should be remanded to the circuit court for an Atkins hearing but otherwise denying relief under Batson and other issues.
(5-3-1: Sullivan for the Court; Randolph concurred in part and in the result, joined by Griffis and Branning, joined in part by Maxwell; King concurred in part and dissented)

Other Orders

  • Melom v. Stone County, Mississippi, 2024-KM-00782-SCT (per curiam affirmance)
  • In Re: Rules Governing Admission to The Mississippi Bar, 89-R-99012-SCT
  • Clark v. State, 2022-DR-00829-SCT (granting in part and denying in part motion for PCR or for leave to proceed in trial court with PCR motion)
  • Chung v. State, 2023-CA-00362-SCT (granting cert)
  • Powers v. State, 2023-DR-00895-SCT (denying cert)
  • Lawson v. State, 2023-CT-01008-SCT (denying cert)
  • Mississippi Baptist Medical Center, Inc. v. Tobias, 2024-M-01395-SCT (denying petition for interlocutory appeal)
  • The Progressive Corporation v. Hanberry, 2025-IA-00109-SCT (granting interlocutory appeal and deciding the case on the petition and response, affirming the denial of a motion to sever but reversing the trial court’s grant of partial summary judgment in the plaintiff’s favor insurance policy dec action)
  • The Mississippi Bar v. Horne-Murry, 2025-BD-00616-SCT (granting petition to transfer respondent to inactive disability status and referring to LJAP)

Hand Down Page

June 26, 2025

In Re: Republican Primary Runoff for Pearl River County Tax Collector/Assessor, Jo Lynn Houston v. Sandy Kane Smith, 2024-EC-00015-SCT (Civil – Election Contest)
Affirming on direct appeal and dismissing cross-appeal in an election contest, holding that the trial court did not err in ordering a special election in two precincts or in finding that certain vote challenges were mere technicalities.
(9-0: Branning for the Court; Randolph did not participate)

City of Jackson, Mississippi v. Maxie, 2023-IA-01314-SCT (Civil – Personal Injury)
Reversing the trial court’s denial of summary judgment in an MTCA personal injury action, holding that the plaintiff did not come forward with evidence that there was a dangerous condition of which the defendants had actual or constructive notice and time to correct or warn against.
(9-0: Coleman for the Court)

Cole v. State, 2024-KA-00041-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of one count of attempted statutory rape, holding that the admission of the victim’s interview did not violate the Confrontation Clause or amount to error under the evidentiary rules, that the admission of the CAD report with a date that was off by one century was not plain error, that there was no plain error in the admission of the State’s expert’s testimony on the victim’s veracity or the State’s characterization of that testimony, and that the cumulative error doctrine did not apply.
(9-0: King for the Court)

Other Orders

  • In Re: The Mississippi Access to Justice Commission, 89-R-99032-SCT ((1) directing the Mississippi Bar, effective July 1, 2025, to remit all pro hac vice fees received under M.R.A.P. 46(b)(5) monthly to the Administrative Office of Courts with two-thirds of the fees to be deposited in the Civil Legal Assistance Fund established by Miss. Code Section 9-21-43 (Rev. 2019) and one-third of the fees to be deposited in the Access to Justice Fund, and (2) directing the Mississippi Bar on or before November 1 of each year to file with this Court an annual report accounting for the receipt of all pro hac vice funds under Rule 46(b)(5))
  • In Re: The Mississippi Access to Justice Commission, 89-R-99032-SCT (order (1) directing the Mississippi Bar, effective July 1, 2025, to remit all funds received by it under Mississippi Rule of Professional Conduct 6.1 monthly to the Administrative Office of Courts to be deposited in the Access to Justice Fund, (2) directing the Mississippi Bar, effective July 1, 2025, to remit all funds currently held in Guaranty Bank Checking Account No. *2492 (The Mississippi Bar Access to Justice account) to the Administrative Office of Courts to be deposited in the Access to Justice Fund, and (3) directing the Mississippi Bar on or before June 1 of each year to file with this Court an annual report accounting for the receipt of all funds under Mississippi Rule of Professional Conduct 6.1.)
  • Ambrose v. State, 2022-DR-00949-SCT (granting State’s motion to dimiss)
  • Ambrose v. State, 2024-CA-00897-SCT (granting motion for voluntary dismissal)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of June 12, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down three opinions today. One is a unique decision addressing sovereign immunity, full faith and credit, and comity. One is a chapter in a post-foreclosure eviction saga. The last is an appeal of a felony conviction with a Lindsey brief.

The Promenade D’Iberville, LLC v. Jacksonville Electric Authority, 2023-CA-01273-SCT (Civil – Other)
Reversing dismissal of a claim against a utility from another state for lack of subject matter jurisdiction based on sovereign immunity, holding that the suit for damages against the utility did not violate full faith and credit or comity principles.
(9-0: Sullivan for the Court)

Federal National Mortgage Association v. Carbo, 2024-CA-00277-SCT (Civil – Real Property)
Affirming the county court’s decision granting a homeowner’s motion to dismiss a claim for eviction and back rent filed by the company that purchased the home in a foreclosure sale but subsequently sold it, holding that the trial court did not err in denying the company’s motion to substitute the subsequent purchaser as plaintiff, in dismissing the company’s suit for lack of standing, or in finding that the company’s suit was barred by res judicata.
(9-0: Coleman for the Court)

Clark v. State, 2024-KA-00446-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of trafficking eutylone, holding that after reviewing counsel’s Lindsey brief, the pro se brief, and the record, that the appeal lacked merit and no issues warranted supplemental briefing.
(9-0: King for the Court)

Other Orders

  • Jordan v. State, 1998-DP-00901-SCT (denying motion for rehearing as to execution date)
  • Arnold v. State, 2023-CT-00519-SCT (denying cert)
  • Federal National Mortgage Association v. Carbo, 2024-CA-00277-SCT (denying motion to dismiss for lack of standing)
  • Jordan v. State, 2024-DR-01272-SCT (denying rehearing)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of June 5, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down two decisions today. One opinion reversed the chancellor’s rulings in an estate matter and the other reversed the Court of Appeals and reinstated a judgment of conviction.

In Re Estate of Brent: Mays v. Estate of Brent, 2023-CA-00423-SCT (Wills, Trusts & Estates)
Reversing the chancellor’s decision giving the ex-wife’s Estate an award for unpaid alimony, holding that the chancellor erred by denying the ex-husband Estate credit for partial alimony payments and for life insurance proceeds which resulted in credits exceeding the total amount owed leaving no unpaid alimony.
(9-0: Ishee for the Court)

Allen v. State, 2022-CT-00419-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Reversing the Court of Appeals and reinstating the judgment of the Yazoo County Circuit Court’s convicting the defendant of six counts of statutory rape, holding that the invited-error doctrine applied because the trial court gave the instructions the defendant requested, that there was no merit to the ineffective-assistance-0f-counsel claim, that the verdict was supported by sufficient evidence, that the defendant waived objections to the application of the tender-years exception, and that the trial court did not err in denying a Batson challenge.
(6-3: Maxwell for the Court; King dissented, joined in part by Coleman and Sullivan; Coleman dissented, joined by Sullivan)

Other Orders

  • In Re: The Rules of Civil Procedure, 89-R-99001-SCT (granting motion to amend M.R.C.P. forms)
  • In Re: The Rules of Civil Procedure, 89-R-99001-SCT (granting motion to amend M.R.C.P. 13)
  • In Re: MEC’s Administrative Procedures,  89-R-99040-SCT (dismissing petition to amend Mississippi Rules of Court by MEC director)
  • In Re: Uniform Procedures for Data Collection Matters in Circuit, Chancery and County Courts,89-R-99042-SCT (dismissing petition to amend Mississippi Rules of Court by MEC director)
  • Smith v. State, 2019-DR-01492-SCT (denying rehearing)
  • Tisdale v. South Central Regional Medical Center, 2023-CT-00231-SCT (denying cert)
  • Hunter v. State, 2023-KA-01246-SCT (denying rehearing)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of May 29, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down two opinions today. One handles four consolidated cases on interlocutory appeal where the defendants contested consolidation and denial of severance. The other case is a direct appeal of murder convictions.

Freese v. Estate of Alford, 2023-IA-00332-SCT consolidated with 2023-IA-00333-SCT, 2023-IA-00335-SCT, 2023-IA-00336-SCT (Civil – Contract)
Affirming the circuit court’s decision adopting the special master’s recommendation granting the plaintiffs’ motions to consolidate claims related to the defendants’ handing and distribution of settlement funds from mass-tort actions and denying the defendants’ motions to sever and re-open discovery, holding that there was no error in consolidating the cases under Rule 20(a), there was no error consolidating under Rule 42(a) and denying severance under Rule 42(b), and there was no abuse of discretion in denying the defendants’ motions to re-open discovery.
(9-0)

Coleman v. State, 2023-KA-01103-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of two counts of first-degree murder, holding that the verdict was not against the overwhelming weight of the evidence.
(9-0)

Other Orders

  • Eason v. South Central Regional Medical Center, 2023-CT-00261-SCT (denying cert)
  • Williams v. State, 2023-CT-00346-SCT (denying cert)
  • In the Interest of A.R.H., a Minor: Malone v. Jackson County Department of Child Protection Services, 2023-CT-00420-SCT (granting cert)
  • Simmons v. State, 2023-CT-00518-SCT (denying cert)
  • Hawkins v. State, 2023-KA-00978-SCT (denying rehearing)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of May 8, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down one opinion in a dog-bite case on interlocutory appeal. The Court also entered an order setting an execution date in a capital case.

TLM Investments, LLC v. Yates, 2024-IA-00204-SCT (Civil – Personal Injury)
Reversing the circuit court’s denial of summary judgment in a dog-bite case, holding that the plaintiff did not come forward with evidence that the property owner/lessor had actual or constructive knowledge of a tenant’s dog or of its dangerous propensities or that the plaintiff was an intended third-party beneficiary of the lease agreement.
(9-0)

Other Orders

  • Jordan v. State, 1998-DP-00901-SCT (granting motion to set execution date)
  • Shoemaker v. State, 2019-M-00832 (denying application for leave to proceed in the trial court, finding the motion frivolous, and restricting the petitioner from filing further PCR petitions in forma pauperis)
  • Magee v. State, 2023-CT-00008-SCT (denying cert)
  • Howell v. State, 2023-CT-00265-SCT (denying cert)
  • Cauthen v. State, 2023-CT-00589-SCT (denying cert)
  • Walker v. State, 2023-KA-01153-SCT (denying rehearing)
  • Jordan v. State, 2024-DR-01272-SCT (denying motion for leave to file PCR motion)
  • Jordan v. State, 2024-DR-01272-SCT (denying State’s motion to dismiss fifth PCR petition and denying defendant’s motion to strike)
  • Timmons v. State, 2025-M-00057 (granting leave to file motion for PCR)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of May 1, 2025

The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down two opinions yesterday. One is a MDOR case and the other is a direct criminal appeal. The Court also entered orders amending the Rules for Court Reporters and the Justice Court Rules.

Mississippi Department of Revenue v. Tennessee Gas Pipeline Company, LLC, 2023-SA-01079-SCT (Civil – State Boards & Agencies)
Affirming the chancery court’s grant of summary judgment against the MDOR, holding that MDOR improperly included freight charges in the taxpayer’s use-tax base where the taxpayer hired a third-party carrier for the shipment of the goods in a closed transaction.
(7-1-0: Sullivan specially concurred, joined by Ishee; Randolph did not participate)

Tubbs v. State, 2023-KA-01124-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of two counts of first-degree murder and two counts of desecration of a human corpse, holding that the conviction was supported by sufficient evidence and that the trial court did not commit plain error by not excluding a deputy’s testimony about the defendant’s confession.
(9-0)

Other Orders

  • Rules for Court Reporters, 89-R-99021-SCT (granting Petition of the Mississippi Court Reporters Association to Amend Rules I(U) and IX(E)(6) of the Rules and Regulations Governing Certified Court Reporters)
  • In Re: Justice Court Rules, 89-R-99024-SCT (amending Rules 9, 14, and 27 of the Rules of Justice Court)
  • Shanks v. State, 2023-CT-00271-SCT (denying cert)
  • Johnson v. SW Gambling LLC, 2023-CT-00505-SCT (denying cert)

Hand Down Page

Mississippi Supreme Court Decisions of April 3, 10, 17, and 24, 2025

Here is Part 2 of my April catch-up posting. The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down nine opinions over the past four weeks. On April 3, appellants went 2-1 with a wills and estates undue-influence case, a divorce case, and an MTCA case with a seven-justice special concurrence addressing confusion in the post-Brantley era. Over the following three weeks there was a case addressing a name-change petition on behalf of a minor undergoing gender transition. There is also a case where a majority of the supreme court justices were unhappy with–but affirmed–the application of one of the Court’s rules requiring a defense attorney had to pay jury costs as part of his client’s plea bargain.

April 3, 2025

In Re Estate of Autry: Autry v. Autry, 2023-CA-01300-SCT (Civil – Wills, Trusts & Estates)
Affirming the chancery court’s order invalidating warranty deeds and a last will and testament, holding that the will was invalid because it was not duly authenticated and that the warranty deeds were the product of undue influence.
(9-0)

Sistrunk v. Sistrunk, 2023-CA-01130-SCT (Civil – Domestic Relations)
Reversing the chancellor’s judgment in a divorce case, holding that the court erred by not making specific findings of fact supported by evidence for each of the Ferguson factors and that as a result the court also erred in its rulings on alimony, child support, use of the martial home, determination of marital assets, and attorney’s fees.
(9-0)

J.S. by and through Segroves v. Ocean Springs School District, 2023-CA-01009-SCT (Civil – Personal Injury)
Reversing the trial court’s grant of summary judgment in an MTCA case, holding (1) that discretionary-function immunity protected the defendant from claims that it failed to adopt sufficient policies and procedure, (2) that the plaintiff’s claims regarding negligent hiring, supervision, and training are claims sound in simple negligence and should not have been dismissed, and (3) that the plaintiff demonstrated a triable issue of fact on foreseeability.
(6-7*-1-0: Maxwell specially concurred, joined by Coleman, Chamberlin, Ishee, Griffis, Sullivan, and Branning; Griffis concurred in part and in the result without writing; Randolph did not participate)

Note – You know what that sound means… Justice Maxwell has written another special concurrence that garnered enough votes to have precedential effect. This concurrence addressed ongoing confusion in MTCA law after Wilcher overruled Brantley:

Other Orders

  • Georgen v. Estate of Brown-Barrett, 2023-CT-00344-SCT (denying cert)
  • Robinson v. State, 2023-KA-00773-SCT (denying rehearing)
  • Miller v. State, 2023-CT-00812-SCT (denying cert)
  • Adams v. State, 2025-M-00014 (denying petition for writ of habeas corpus in the nature of a post-conviction application, and finding that the filing was frivolous

Hand Down Page

April 10, 2025

Hawkins v. State, 2023-KA-00978-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of one count of sexual battery and two counts of fondling, holding that the conviction was supported by sufficient evidence and that the verdict was not against the overwhelming weight of the evidence, and that the second trial did not violate double jeopardy where the first trial ended in mistrial due to juror misconduct.
(9-0)

Other Orders

  • LaFleur v. State, 2022-CT-00500-SCT (denying cert)
  • Wilkerson v. Allred, 2023-CT-00393-SCT (denying cert)
  • Fox v. Allen Automotive, Inc., 2023-CT-00441-SCT (denying cert)
  • Phillips v. Forrest County Industrial Park Commission, 2023-CT-01132-SCT (dismissing cert petition)
  • Williams v. Mississippi Farm Bureau Casualty Insurance Company, 2023-CA-01225-SCT (denying rehearing)

Hand Down Page

April 17, 2025

In the Matter of S.M. v. Mississippi State Board of Health, 2023-CA-01379-SCT (Civil – Other)
Affirming the chancellor’s decision denying a minor female’s petition to legally change her name to a more masculine name as part of a gender transition, holding that the chancellor did not abuse her discretion in determining that the child needed to mature more before refiling her request and that the chancellor was not required to apply the Albright factors in reaching that decision.
(8-1: King dissented)

Mississippi Apartment Association v. City of Jackson, 2023-CA-01068-SCT (Civil – Other)
Affirming the chancery court’s decision granting a motion to dismiss an action seeking injunctions based on interpretations and enforcement of city ordinances, holding that the circuit court had exclusive jurisdiction in a previously-filed action challenging the City’s decision to adopt and also hand pendent jurisdiction over the equitable claims in chancery court.
(5-4: Coleman dissented, joined by Branning, Maxwell, and Griffis; Maxwell dissented, joined by Griffis, and joined in part by Coleman, and Branning)

In Re: Jex, 2024-CP-00291-SCT (Civil – Other)
Affirming the circuit court’s order requiring the defendant’s attorney to pay jury costs, holding that the record confirmed that the attorney voluntarily agreed to do so as part of negotiating a plea bargain for his client.
(4-5*-3: Chamberlin specially concurred, joined by Maxwell, Ishee, Griffis, and Branning; Sullivan dissented, joined by King and Coleman)

Note – Chamberlin’s special concurrence has a total of five votes giving it precedential value. Both the special concurrence and the dissent note some difficult facts in this case and the duress, albeit not “legal duress” the State put the defense attorney under.

Final Note – I count eight votes from the rule-making body unhappy with the application of a rule in this case (Rule 3.13 of the Uniform Civil Rules of Circuit and County Court Practice). See Newell v. State, 308 So. 2d 71 (Miss. 1975).

Other Orders

  • In Re: State Intervention Courts Advisory Committee, 89-R-99039-SCT (approving the designation of Katharine Surkin, Director of the Administrative Office of the Courts, of Justice Robert P. Chamberlin as Chair of the State Intervention Courts Advisory Committee and the following as members through December 31, 2026: Judge Michael M. Taylor, Judge Winston L. Kidd, Judge Robert Helfrich, Judge Charles E. Webster, Judge Kathy King Jackson, Judge Randi P. Mueller, Judge John White, Nathan Blevins Deputy Commissioner of Community Corrections, MDOC, Representative Kevin Horan, Chairman, House Judiciary B Committee, Andrea Sanders, Commissioner, Miss. Department of Child Protection Services, and Consuelo Walley, Coordinator, Jones County Drug Ct, 18th Judicial Circuit, and further designating the following alternate members who may attend and vote in the absence of an appointed committee member: Judge Mary “Betsy” Cotton, Judge Mike Dickinson, Judge Walt Brown and W. Dewayne Richardson, District Attorney, Fourth Circuit Court District.)
  • Brown v. State, 2023-CT-00648-SCT (denying cert)
  • In the Matter of Estate of Johnson: Manners v. Estate of Johnson, 2023-CT-00823-SCT (granting cert)
  • In Re: Administrative Orders of the Supreme Court of Mississippi, 2025-AD-00001-SCT (directing the disbursement of $149,116.92 in civil legal assistance funds among the MS Center for Legal Services, MS Volunteer Lawyers Project, and North MS Rural Legal Services)

Hand Down Page

April 24, 2025

Quinn v. State, 2024-KA-00195-SCT (Criminal – Felony)
Affirming conviction of attempted murder and possession of a firearm by a felon, holding that the trial court did not err by denying the defendant’s proposed jury instruction defining “homicide,” “murder,” and “deliberate design,” and that the evidence was sufficient to support the conviction.
(9-0)

United Emergency Services of Mississippi, Inc. v. Miller, 2023-IA-00767-SCT, consolidated with Baptist Memorial Hospital-Golden Triangle, inc. v. Miller, 2023-IA-00772-SCT (Civil – Wrongful Death)
Affirming in part and reversing in part the circuit court’s denial of the defendants’ motions for summary judgment in a med mal case, holding that the there were genuine issues of material fact as to all claims except those relying on the theory that one defendant-doctor should have admitted the decedent to the hospital.
(9-0)

Other Orders

  • Knight v. State, 2022-KA-01138-SCT (denying rehearing)
  • Middleton v. State, 2024-IA-00144-SCT (denying rehearing)
  • McPhail v. McPhail, 2024-TS-00849 (reinstating appeal)

Hand Down Page