I am declaring an end to the hiatus caused by the tree falling on my house. That war rages on, but these decisions are not going to summarize themselves. I aspire to go back and summarize the decisions handed down while I was down, but I am going to prioritize summarizing new hand downs going forward.
On Tuesday, the Court of Appeals handed down four opinions. One is an appeal of a verdict in a med mal bench trial. The other three are PCR cases, one of which yielded a 5-1-4 split.
Singing River Health System v. Brand, 2022-CA-00090-COA (Civil – Med Mal)
Affirming judgment for the plaintiff in a med mal case against a hospital after a bench trial, holding that the hospital’s vicarious liability argument was procedurally barred because it not raised at the trial court level, that the plaintiff’s experts were qualified to testify about a breach of the standard of care and cause of death and provided sufficient evidence under the “lost chance of recovery” theory, and that there was substantial evidence to support the trial court’s findings.
(8-1-0: Wilson concurred in result only; Lawrence did not participate.)
Tate v. State, 2021-CP-01237-COA (Civil – PCR)
Affirming denial of PCR motion, holding that the trial court did not err determining that there was no evidence showing that the plea of guilt was involuntary or that counsel was ineffective.
(9-0: Emfinger did not participate.)
Havercome v. State, 2022-CA-00391-COA (Civil – PCR)
Affirming dismissal of PCR motion, holding that the motion was barred by the UPCCRA.
(10-0)
Love v. State, 2021-CP-01101-COA (Civil – PCR)
Affirming dismissal of motion for PCR, holding that the trial court did not err in finding that there was a factual basis for his plea, that the please was voluntary, that the claim to withdraw his plea was time-barred, and that counsel was not ineffective.
(5-1-4: McDonald concurred in part and in the result without written opinion; Emfinger dissented, joined by Wilson, Westbrooks, and McCarty, and joined in part by McDonald.)
Other Orders
Alford v. State, 2022-KA-00025-COA (denying rehearing)
Hopes v. State, 2022-KA-COA (denying rehearing)
Mississippi Appeals Blog 