The Mississippi Supreme Court handed down one opinion today in an interesting case addressing the applicability of the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine that yielded a total of four opinions. The Court also granted cert in three significant cases covering three very different areas of law: (1) a direct criminal appeal where the COA affirmed a conviction of sexual battery over a dissent finding a Confrontation Clause violation, (2) a PCR case where the COA held an indictment was defective but the claim was procedurally barred, and (3) a civil case where the COA reversed summary judgment because it said there was a question of fact whether car wreck was the proximate cause of opioid misuse and death.
Beachy v. Mississippi District for Assemblies of God, 2021-CA-01007-SCT (Civil – Contract)
Reversing the chancellor’s ruling in a dec action brought by the District against a particular church and its board of trustees that had sought to disaffiliate with the District and remove a reverter clause in its constitution and bylawys that would have caused the church’s property to revert to the District, holding that issues concerning disaffiliation are church-governing matters and that the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine deprived the chancellor of jurisdiction over but that there was a genuine issue of material fact concerning the issue of property ownership.
(5-2-2: Maxwell specially concurred, joined by Coleman, Beam, and Chamberlin, and joined in part by Ishee; Ishee concurred in part and dissented in part joined in part by Maxwell; Randolph dissented, joined by Griffis)
Other Orders
Hathorne v. State, 2021-CT-00306-SCT (granting cert) (a 2-4-4 COA affirmed denial of motion for PCT, holding that the indictment was defective for failing to charge a crime but that the claim was procedurally barred)
Barfield v. State, 2021-CT-00660-SCT (denying cert)
Pitts v. State, 2021-CT-00740-SCT (granting cert) (a 6-1-2 COA affirmed conviction of sexual battery after a screen was placed between the child and the defendant; Judge Wilson’s dissent argued that the use of the screen was a violation of the Confrontation Clause)
Clark v. Tippah County Dept. of CPS, 2021-CT-01209-SCT (denying cert)
Smith v. Minier, 2021-CT-01284 (granting cert) (the COA reversed summary judgment dismissing wrongful death claim where decedent died of chronic liver failure five months after a car wreck, holding that there was a fact question as to whether the at-fault driver’s actions were proximate cause of decedent’s use of pain meds, misuse of pain meds, and resulting death)
Penn-Star Ins. Co. v. Thompson, 2022-IA-00106-SCT (denying rehearing)